Neutering – YES or NO?? Would appreciate an answer ASAP

Welcome to your reliable resource for online holistic veterinary help Forums Pet Owners Forum Surgical Problems Neutering – YES or NO?? Would appreciate an answer ASAP

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
  • Author
  • #2050
    Tony Scott


    This message board is a wonderful way to communicate! Thanks for making it available!

    My question is about neutering my 8 month old yellow lab. He is scheduled for sugery on Monday morning, but after reading someone’s response to my query on Classical Homeopathy Pets in Yahoo Groups, I’m having doubts about going through with the surgery. Here is the answer to my posting: Your 7 month old lab is way to young to be neutered. You need to wait until he has reached maturity. The hormones you will be eliminating by neutering him are essential to his growth. Forget the remedies – cancel the appointment!!

    She also wrote:

    1. A healthy dog, free from vaccinosis and chronic disease, will not have
    “male associated behavior problems.”

    2. Suprressing symptoms, such as “male associated behavior problems” will
    drive the chronic disease deeper into the life force and the chronic disease
    will then manifest itself in the form of more serious symptoms.

    3. Removing hormones is suppression.

    Therefore, if your reason for castration is simply to remove these
    behaviors, you are causing great harm to your animal!!! You need to educate
    yourself before you take such a drastic step. I am not telling you to leave
    the dog in tact for life but there is no reason that a healthy dog needs to
    be castrated. Knowing what I do now, I will never alter another of my
    animals. In fact, I spoke with the breeder of my next puppy and told her
    how I felt so that we could come to an understanding. Removing sexual
    organs has become the social norm in this country because pet owners are too lazy and irresponsible. So, now, we are affecting the health of our beloved pets simply for our own convenience.

    If you are going to neuter this dog at least wait until he has reached full
    maturity. My guess for a male lab would be two years.

    What should I do? Help!


    Dr. Jeff Feinman

    [quote=Pruffles]You need to educate
    yourself before you take such a drastic step.

    What should I do? Help![/quote]

    Hi Pilar-

    Welcome!! First of all I definitely agree that it is very important to be an educated health care consumer.

    Castration can indeed be suppressive (from a homeopathic perspective). Anytime a treatment is directed strictly at a single symptom, e.g. neutering to stop intermale aggression or ear ointment to treat an ear “infection” etc., it can be suppressive. Appropriate (curative) therapy always takes the entire picture into account.

    From a strictly physiological point of view I also agree that it is better for some dogs to get castrated after developing secondary sex characteristics. For example, many people like the “fat head” appearance of male Goldens and Labs. This will not develop if they are neutered before sexual maturity.

    I’d love to discuss this further but we should do so in the homeopathy folder.

    Dr. Jeff

    BTW-In the future, please log in before posting so I can give your question priority treatment.


    Hi Dr. Jeff,

    Thank you for your reply. If I do decide to have my lab castrated, can you tell me what other homeopathic remedies besides Arnica I should give him pre and post op to help ease his discomfort and to assist in the recovery time?

    Thank you.

    Dr. Jeff Feinman

    [quote=pruffles]can you tell me what other homeopathic remedies besides Arnica I should give him pre and post op to help ease his discomfort and to assist in the recovery time[/quote]

    Sorry about the delay in replying Pilar-

    There can be many useful post-surgical remedies depending on your dog’s state after surgery. Often a remedy is not needed if the patient’s homeostasis is already strong enough. Sometimes repetition of the constitutional remedy is indicated.

    If an acute injury remedy is called for post-surgically it could be Arnica, or Bellis-p, Staphy, Aconite, Hypericum, etc.

    Good luck with the neutering.


    So Pilar are you having your lab neutered or not? I have two yorkies that are 2 years old and have not neutered them yet. I feel that it is torture to an animal. The vets all tell me it is the best thing for your pet, but I feel as though, how will they know if it is the best and how will they know for sure if they will get testicular cancer???? So I am still debating if I want to neuter them, so whatever you know, please pass it along. Which site did you get that info from?

    Dr. Jeff Feinman

    This is the summary of an important article for anyone who wants to make an informed decision about neutering:

    An objective reading of the veterinary medical literature reveals a complex situation with respect to the longterm
    health risks and benefits associated with spay/neuter in dogs. The evidence shows that spay/neuter
    Page 2 of 12
    correlates with both positive AND adverse health effects in dogs. It also suggests how much we really do
    not yet understand about this subject.
    On balance, it appears that no compelling case can be made for neutering most male dogs, especially
    immature male dogs, in order to prevent future health problems. The number of health problems associated
    with neutering may exceed the associated health benefits in most cases.
    On the positive side, neutering male dogs
    • eliminates the small risk (probably <1%) of dying from testicular cancer
    • reduces the risk of non-cancerous prostate disorders
    • reduces the risk of perianal fistulas
    • may possibly reduce the risk of diabetes (data inconclusive)
    On the negative side, neutering male dogs
    • if done before 1 year of age, significantly increases the risk of osteosarcoma (bone cancer); this is a
    common cancer in medium/large and larger breeds with a poor prognosis.
    • increases the risk of cardiac hemangiosarcoma by a factor of 1.6
    • triples the risk of hypothyroidism
    • increases the risk of progressive geriatric cognitive impairment
    • triples the risk of obesity, a common health problem in dogs with many associated health problems
    • quadruples the small risk (<0.6%) of prostate cancer
    • doubles the small risk (5; this is a common cancer and major cause of death in some breeds
    • triples the risk of hypothyroidism
    • increases the risk of obesity by a factor of 1.6-2, a common health problem in dogs with many
    associated health problems
    • causes urinary “spay incontinence” in 4-20% of female dogs
    • increases the risk of persistent or recurring urinary tract infections by a factor of 3-4
    • increases the risk of recessed vulva, vaginal dermatitis, and vaginitis, especially for female dogs
    spayed before puberty
    • doubles the small risk (<1%) of urinary tract tumors
    • increases the risk of orthopedic disorders
    • increases the risk of adverse reactions to vaccinations
    One thing is clear – much of the spay/neuter information that is available to the public is unbalanced and
    contains claims that are exaggerated or unsupported by evidence. Rather than helping to educate pet
    Page 3 of 12
    owners, much of it has contributed to common misunderstandings about the health risks and benefits
    associated of spay/neuter in dogs.
    The traditional spay/neuter age of six months as well as the modern practice of pediatric spay/neuter appear
    to predispose dogs to health risks that could otherwise be avoided by waiting until the dog is physically
    mature, or perhaps in the case of many male dogs, foregoing it altogether unless medically necessary.
    The balance of long-term health risks and benefits of spay/neuter will vary from one dog to the next. Breed,
    age, and gender are variables that must be taken into consideration in conjunction with non-medical factors
    for each individual dog. Across-the-board recommendations for all pet dogs do not appear to be
    supportable from findings in the veterinary medical literature.
    This section summarizes the diseases or conditions that have been studied with respect to spay/neuter in
    Complications from Spay/Neuter Surgery
    All surgery incurs some risk of complications, including adverse reactions to anesthesia, hemorrhage,
    inflammation, infection, etc. Complications include only immediate and near term impacts that are clearly
    linked to the surgery, not to longer term impacts that can only be assessed by research studies.
    At one veterinary teaching hospital where complications were tracked, the rates of intraoperative,
    postoperative and total complications were 6.3%, 14.1% and 20.6%, respectively as a result of spaying
    female dogs1. Other studies found a rate of total complications from spaying of 17.7%2 and 23%3. A study
    of Canadian veterinary private practitioners found complication rates of 22% and 19% for spaying female
    dogs and neutering male dogs, respectively4.
    Serious complications such as infections, abscesses, rupture of the surgical wound, and chewed out sutures
    were reported at a 1- 4% frequency, with spay and castration surgeries accounting for 90% and 10% of
    these complications, respectively.4
    The death rate due to complications from spay/neuter is low, at around 0.1%2.
    Prostate Cancer
    Much of the spay/neuter information available to the public asserts that neutering will reduce or eliminate the
    risk that male dogs develop prostate cancer. This would not be an unreasonable assumption, given that
    prostate cancer in humans is linked to testosterone. But the evidence in dogs does not support this claim.
    In fact, the strongest evidence suggests just the opposite.
    There have been several conflicting epidemiological studies over the years that found either an increased
    risk or a decreased risk of prostate cancer in neutered dogs. These studies did not utilize control
    populations, rendering these results at best difficult to interpret. This may partially explain the conflicting
    More recently, two retrospective studies were conducted that did utilize control populations. One of these
    studies involved a dog population in Europe5 and the other involved a dog population in America6. Both
    studies found that neutered male dogs have a four times higher risk of prostate cancer than intact dogs.
    Based on their results, the researchers suggest a cause-and-effect relationship: “this suggests that
    castration does not initiate the development of prostatic carcinoma in the dog, but does favor tumor
    progression”5 and also “Our study found that most canine prostate cancers are of ductal/urothelial
    origin….The relatively low incidence of prostate cancer in intact dogs may suggest that testicular hormones
    Page 4 of 12
    are in fact protective against ductal/urothelial prostatic carcinoma, or may have indirect effects on cancer
    development by changing the environment in the prostate.”6
    This needs to be put in perspective. Unlike the situation in humans, prostate cancer is uncommon in dogs.
    Given an incidence of prostate cancer in dogs of less than 0.6% from necropsy studies7, it is difficult to see
    that the risk of prostate cancer should factor heavily into most neutering decisions. There is evidence for an
    increased risk of prostate cancer in at least one breed (Bouviers)5, though very little data so far to guide us
    in regards to other breeds.
    Testicular Cancer
    Since the testicles are removed with neutering, castration removes any risk of testicular cancer (assuming
    the castration is done before cancer develops). This needs to be compared to the risk of testicular cancer in
    intact dogs.
    Testicular tumors are not uncommon in older intact dogs, with a reported incidence of 7%8. However, the
    prognosis for treating testicular tumors is very good owing to a low rate of metastasis9, so testicular cancer
    is an uncommon cause of death in intact dogs. For example, in a Purdue University breed health survey of
    Golden Retrievers10, deaths due to testicular cancer were sufficiently infrequent that they did not appear on
    list of significant causes of "Years of Potential Life Lost for Veterinary Confirmed Cause of Death” even
    though 40% of GR males were intact. Furthermore, the GRs who were treated for testicular tumors had a
    90.9% cure rate. This agrees well with other work that


    This is an ethical problem. We live in a world where being yourself isn’t enough anymore. Why do we need to change everything around just to meet some other people’s standards? I will never neuter my dog because I love him as he is and I know he has his needs. We don’t do it to our kids, do we? I think of Ad (my other husky pup) as one of my kids.

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
  • The forum ‘Surgical Problems’ is closed to new topics and replies.
Do you have a sick animal?

If so take a moment and head over to Holistic Actions where you will:

Feel more confident making HOLISTIC MEDICAL DECISIONS

Focus on PREVENTION and avoid un-needed and expensive diagnostics and treatments

Enhance your pets QUALITY OF LIFE and HAPPINESS

You can now find Dr. Jeff at Holistic Actions!
I'm sending my prayers and best wishes to everyone throughout the world that has been affected by this historic pandemic. My hope is for a better balance of the world and greater empowerment for all as soon as possible. Here are 4 actions that can be used today to improve immune resistance to any virus or bacteria:

1. Go on a "sniff walk” with your pet and breathe fresh air deeply for at least 30 minutes/day.

2. Eat darkly colored fresh vegetables and fruit such as wild blueberries and kale.

3. Do at least 50 HA! breaths just say ha loudly) daily. These forceful expulsions of air help maintain good lung function and can help you detect respiratory problems early. Laughter, coughing and Kapalabhati breathing (from yoga) are three other easy ways to do this.

4. Experience positive emotions, like the sense of awe, when we witness the renewal of nature. Stay safe, Vital and healthy”

Holistic Actions! membership includes a free monthly 15 minute consultation to discuss your Holistic Medical Decision Making. To discuss other Holistic Actions!, and to learn more about the Vitality and Balance System which describes how they work on a molecular level, just register as a Gold member at www.holisticactions.com/membership and schedule time to talk.

Stay safe, Vital and healthy,

Dr. Jeff